Rights group criticizes proposed EU migrant rules as ‘cruel and unrealistic’ News
tpsdave / Pixabay
Rights group criticizes proposed EU migrant rules as ‘cruel and unrealistic’

Human Rights Watch on Thursday criticized the proposed European “Returns Regulation” for undocumented migrants as “cruel and unrealistic” by allowing longer detention and harsher treatment.

The European Commission seeks to establish standardized return procedures so that returns of migrants can be more efficient but respect fundamental human rights. For instance, the proposed rule provides mandatory forced return if the undocumented migrant does not cooperate with an EU member state throughout the entire return procedure. Additionally, the special rules for individuals deemed security risks could be detained for more than 24 months with judicial authorization.

The standardized procedures also address the EU’s low return rates and the fragmentation of different national systems. According to the data of the European Parliament, the rate of return decisions being enforced was 23 percent in 2023. The parliament concluded that the data reflect the difficulties faced by EU member states when enforcing the return orders.

Among all EU member states, 27 systems are currently in place to assess whether to return an undocumented migrant. The proposed procedure seeks to unify the system with common procedures and allow for mutual recognition of return decisions by 1 July 2027.

However, HRW argued that imposing harsher obligations on migrants does not address the issue as the principal obstacle to enforcing return decisions is uncooperative countries of origin. According to the Migration Policy Institute, the origin states can reject returnees simply by nonresponse or prolonged bureaucratic procedures. In other words, both origin states and EU member states would not recognize their legal status if the proposal is implemented.

This exacerbates the group’s concern that the revised detention rules would allow the detention of vulnerable individuals, including unaccompanied children. HRW also argued that the return hubs, which would transfer migrants to third countries, fail to guarantee safe and sustainable returns.

The proposal follows the Pact on Migration and Asylum, a 2024 reform introducing new migration rules to create a comprehensive approach. The proposed regulation includes provisions on common procedures for issuing return decisions, rules on forced returns, obligations for returnees, and measures to prevent absconding.

The next step for the proposed regulation is approval from the European Parliament and the Council. HRW has urged the European Parliament to reject the proposal, arguing that it would weaken and undermine EU standards.

Asylum has been a heated topic among the EU member states. On January 7, the European Court of Human Rights found that the Greek authorities systematically engaged in illegally forcing asylum seekers to return to their origin state, violating the 1951 Refugee Convention. On February 19, Poland sought to suspend asylum rights at its border with Belarus.

Relatedly in March, the EU Agency for Asylum reported that asylum applications across the EU, Norway and Switzerland decreased by 11 percent in 2024.

THIS DAY @ LAW

Julius Caesar assassinated on Ides of March

Roman dictator Julius Caesar was assassinated at the Roman Forum by a number of his own senators led by Marcus Brutus on March 15, 44 BC over concerns that he was becoming too powerful. The assassination wound up being a political failure as the Roman citizenry ended up becoming incensed at the conspirators and a civil war broke out, which Brutus and his supporters lost to Mark Antony and Octavian (later Augustus). William Shakespeare later wrote in his eponymous play about the assassination, "Beware the ides of March." Learn more about the assassination of Julius Caesar.

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg born

US Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg was born on March 15, 1933.

Learn more about Justice Ginsburg from Oyez, the Supreme Court multimedia project at Northwestern University.

Code Napoleon promulgated

On March 15, 1803, the Code Napoleon (French Civil Code) was promulgated in France. The Code is considered the first successful legal code in Europe and is still used today as the basis for the modern French Civil Code. Napoleon's conquests spread his Code across the European Continent, influencing modern legal codes in Portugal, Austria, Italy, and other nations. Read a history of the Code Napoleon.