Federal appeals court denies reparations to descendants of first 20th century genocide News
Studiolarsen / Pixabay
Federal appeals court denies reparations to descendants of first 20th century genocide

The US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit on Thursday denied descendants of the victims of the first twentieth-century genocide the ability to collect reparations from Germany.

This putative class action was brought on behalf of members and descendants of the Ovaherero and Nama indigenous peoples. Between 1884 and 1903, Germany colonized present-day Namibia, which was originally occupied by Ovaherero and Nama peoples. During the course of colonization, these peoples were treated as property and enslaved. The UN Economic and Social Council Commission on Human Rights deemed the events a genocide in 1985.

In an effort to seek redress from such events in the US, the Ovaherero and Nama peoples had to prove that the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act (FSIA) was applicable to the present case. Plaintiffs argued that jurisdiction was proper under the FSIA because human remains collected from this colonization period were shipped from Germany to the American Museum of Natural History in New York City. They also argued that the New York Public Library houses one of the few copies of the Blue Book, a record of the genocide of the Ovaherero and Nama peoples.

More specifically, plaintiffs assert that the takings exception if the FSIA is applicable in their case. In order for the takings exception to establish jurisdiction, a plaintiff must show: “(1) rights in property are in issue; (2) that the property was taken; (3) that the taking was in violation of international law; and (4) that one of the two nexus requirements is satisfied.” However, the court disagreed with the contention that the takings exception was applicable in this case. The court reasoned that the complaint “fails to allege that the expropriated property is present in connection with a commercial activity,” rather the New York properties are being used for governmental use.

While the court dismissed this complaint for lack of subject matter jurisdiction, it noted that “the terrible wrongs elucidated in Plaintiffs’ complaint must be addressed through a vehicle other than the U.S. court system.”

THIS DAY @ LAW

Pennsylvania police killed 19 miners during strike

The Luzerne County Sheriff and deputies opened fire on a group of 400 striking miners in the town of Lattimer, Pennsylvania on September 10, 1897. Around 19 strikers were killed, and 39 were injured as a result. Luzerne County Sheriff James Martin and his deputies were later acquitted by a Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania jury after claiming that the strikers advanced upon the police. Learn more about the Lattimer Massacre from the Zinn Education Project and the Pennsylvania Center for the Book.

Sewing machine patented

On September 10, 1846, United States patent number 3640 was awarded to Elias Howe for his sewing machine. In 1854, Howe brought legal action against Isaac Singer, because he alleged Singer's machine infringed upon the patent. Howe won the case and was awarded royalties from the Singer sewing machines. Learn more about Elias Howe from the University of Rochester.

Last French execution by guillotine

On September 10, 1977, Hamida Djandoubi, a Tunisian immigrant convicted of murder, became the last person executed by guillotine in France. The French death penalty was formally abolished by President Francois Mitterand in 1981. Learn more about the history of the guillotine.