Federal judge rejects settlement for Yahoo privacy breach News
© WikiMedia (Sebastian Bergmann)
Federal judge rejects settlement for Yahoo privacy breach

A federal judge denied primary approval on Monday for a proposed settlement in a class action breach lawsuit against Yahoo, citing a continued lack of transparency.

Yahoo was subject to three data breaches between 2013 and 2016. These breaches occurred due to Yahoo’s failure to use “appropriate safeguards to protect users’ personal identification information,” and Yahoo “made a conscious and deliberate decision not to alert any of Yahoo’s customers that their [personal information] had been stolen.” Yahoo’s entire user database was available for purchase on the dark web in 2016, and Yahoo purchased it using bitcoin.

The judge was critical of several issues in the settlement. In addition to inadequate disclosures, the proposed notice does not share the total size of the settlement fund. Without this information class members are unable to assess whether the settlement is reasonable. The judge also found that given the the settlement range (between $69.6–175 million), the attorneys’ fees “substantially exceed[] the 19.4% mean and 19.9% median.”

Additionally, the court found issue with the non-monetary relief, which does little to address security safeguards. This continues to be an issue in data breach cases. Here, the “lack of specific increases in budget or number of employees and the vague commitments as to changed business practices” leaves a significant question regarding the benefit of the settlement.

With this ruling, the parties in this case will need to produce a new settlement agreement. Yahoo has successfully settled other claims against it, including claims of federal securities.

THIS DAY @ LAW

Pope Urban II sparks First Crusade

Pope Urban II threw his support behind what would become the First Crusade on November 27, 1095 during the Council of Clairmont. The Pope urged the council's participants to render aid to the Byzantine Empire, which was being attacked by the Seljuks. Pope Urban called for a wide coalition of rich and poor to combat the threat, which eventually resulted in the conquest of much of the Muslim-controlled Levant by the Crusaders and the establishment of the Crusader States. Read Pope Urban's address.  

Catholic Code of Canon Law revised

On November 27, 1983, the revised Code of Canon Law of the Roman Catholic Church went into effect. Learn more about the history of Canon Law from Professor Kenneth Pennington of the Catholic University of America's Columbus School of Law.

Alfred Nobel creates Nobel Prize in his will

On November 27, 1895, Alfred Nobel signed his will, creating the Nobel Prize. Learn more about the history of the Nobel Prize and the Nobel Commission.