Ruling permitting the Interior Department to stay online [DC Circuit CA] News
Ruling permitting the Interior Department to stay online [DC Circuit CA]

Cobell et al. v. Norton, Secretary of the Interior et al., US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia, December 3, 2004 [ruling that the US Interior Department does not have to disconnect its computers from the Internet despite the possibility of tampering by hackers]. Excerpt:

The district court could not resolve the state of Interior's IT systems security without conducting a hearing on the evidence in dispute.In opposition to the plaintiffs' motion for injunctive relief mandating disconnection of Interior's IT systems from the Internet,the Secretary described various measures taken and underway by Interior to secure IT systems,and disputed that such drastic relief was necessary. Almost nine months had passed since the hearing for the July 28,2003 injunction.Under the circumstances,the court abused its discretion by not holding an evidentiary hearing before issuing the March 15,2004 injunction.

Read the full text of the opinion here. Reported in JURIST's Paper Chase here.