 |
|

Legal news from Thursday, September 17, 2009 |
 |
|


Federal judge orders Pittsburgh to grant permit for G-20 'tent city' demonstration
Jaclyn Belczyk on September 17, 2009 4:17 PM ET

[JURIST] A judge in the US District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania [official website] ruled Thursday that the City of Pittsburgh [official website] must allow a tent city protest during next week's Group of 20 (G-20) [official website] summit [official website], but that it could deny permits to two other groups. In response to a lawsuit [JURIST report] brought last week by the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) and the Center for Constitutional Rights (CCR) [advocacy websites], Judge Gary Lancaster ruled [Pittsburgh Post-Gazette report] that the city must issue a permit to CodePink [advocacy website] to set up a tent city in Point State Park [official website] in the days before the summit. Lancaster also ruled that the city could deny permits to the Thomas Merton Center [advocacy website] to hold a march through downtown and rally on a bridge and to other groups wishing to camp overnight in Schenley Park [official website]. CCR Vice President and University of Pittsburgh School of Law professor Jules Lobel said [press release]:
We regret the judge did not see eye-to-eye with us in allowing the groups to camp and rally. ... It is a still a great victory, however, that CodePink and Three Rivers Climate Convergence will be able to erect a symbolic tent city in the main park in downtown Pittsburgh and be heard during the G-20.
Since the suit was filed, the city granted permits [NYT report] to three of the original plaintiffs - the G6 Billion group and Bail Out the People, seeking to hold marches, and a group of artists seeking to use a city park.
Earlier this week, the Pittsburgh City Council [official website] passed [JURIST report] an ordinance [text, PDF] in anticipation of the G-20 summit that will allow police to cite people in possession of certain items if they intend to use them unlawfully. The temporary ordinance, passed in anticipation of protests at the summit scheduled for September 24 and 25, expires at the end of the month. It prohibits the possession of tools or other items such as handcuffs, padlocks, and pipes with an intent to use those items to block access to streets, sidewalks, and public buildings or to defeat crowd control orders. A proposal to ban masks and hoods [text, PDF] during the summit was voted down [Pittsburgh Post-Gazette report] by the City Council last week.


Link |
|
subscribe |
|
latest newscast |
archive |
Facebook page

|

UK government to review control order system
Jaclyn Belczyk on September 17, 2009 3:28 PM ET

[JURIST] UK Home Secretary Alan Johnson [official profile] said Wednesday that the government will conduct a review of the control order [Guardian backgrounder; JURIST news archive] house arrest system in light of a June Law Lords ruling [judgment, PDF; JURIST report] requiring the government to let detainees know generally what charges they face so that they can mount a defense. Johnson issued a ministerial statement [text] saying that his "current assessment is ... that the control order regime remains viable," but that he would "be keeping this assessment under review." Speaking before the Police Superintendents' annual conference, Johnson said [text]: [Control orders] are not and never were intended to be the first line of defence.
Where an individual is suspected of terrorist activity, our first objective will always be for that person to be tried and prosecuted in an open court, or deported if they are foreign nationals.
But there is a very small number of people who undoubtedly pose a substantial threat to public safety, and who for good reason, we can neither prosecute nor deport. ...
Control orders are a practical and proportionate legislative tool that can be applied in such cases. They are not perfect and one day, I hope they won't be necessary. But for a handful of people, they remain the best option we have for ensuring the public is safe and our security services are able to do their work effectively. That is why I announced in a ministerial statement issued an hour ago that I have decided to maintain the availability of control orders within the constrains of the House of Lords judgement. Johnson also announced that he had asked the independent reviewer of the Prevention of Terrorism Act 2005 [text], Lord Carlile of Berriew [official profile], to review the impact of the Law Lords judgment.
Johnson's announcement comes as last week, the UK Home Office [official website] released a top terrorism suspect [JURIST report] from a control order because it did not want to reveal secret evidence. In August, a control order against a suspected terrorist known as AN was overturned [judgment text; JURIST report] by the UK High Court. At that time Johnson had announced plans [BBC report] to draft a new control order against AN. The UK Law Lords ruled [JURIST report] in a series of decisions last October that the government can continue to impose control orders on terror suspects in lieu of detention, but said that some elements of the orders violate human rights. Control orders allow the British government to conduct surveillance and impose house arrest on suspects where there does not exist enough evidence to prosecute. The orders can also be used to forbid the use of mobile phones and the Internet.


Link |
|
subscribe |
|
latest newscast |
archive |
Facebook page

|

Virginia court sets November execution date for DC sniper
Andrew Morgan on September 17, 2009 2:31 PM ET

[JURIST] A Virginia court on Wednesday set a November 10 execution date for John Allen Muhammad [BBC profile], who was convicted of murder in 2005 for his role in a series of DC-area sniper shootings [JURIST news archive]. Prosecutors had sought to schedule [AP report] the execution for Monday, November 9, but Judge Mary Grace O'Brien of the Prince William County Circuit Court [official website] moved the date back one day to allow for last minute appeals [BBC report]. Muhammad's attorneys plan [AFP report] to ask Virginia governor Timothy Kaine for clemency, and to appeal Muhammad's death sentence to the US Supreme Court.
In August, the US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit [official website] upheld [JURIST report] the Virginia death sentence, despite Muhammad's allegations of "nondisclosure of exculpatory information by the prosecution" and "ineffective assistance of ... trial counsel." In 2007, the Maryland Court of Special Appeals [official website] ruled [JURIST report] that a Maryland court did not err in finding Muhammad competent to stand trial in Maryland. Muhammad was sentenced in Maryland in June 2006 to six consecutive life terms in prison without the possibility of parole following his conviction [JURIST reports] by a Maryland jury of six counts of murder. Maryland prosecutors did not seek the death penalty but wanted a second conviction in case his earlier Virginia conviction [JURIST reports] was overturned on appeal. Accomplice Lee Boyd Malvo [BBC profile], who pleaded guilty to the Virginia charges and received a life sentence, testified [JURIST reports] in the Maryland case that Muhammad pulled the trigger in five of the six killings there.


Link |
|
subscribe |
|
latest newscast |
archive |
Facebook page

|

US seeking 60-day delay in Guantanamo military trials
Brian Jackson on September 17, 2009 12:30 PM ET

[JURIST] The Obama administration on Wednesday sought a two-month delay [brief, PDF] in trials for detainees at Guantanamo Bay [JURIST news archive] while new options are considered. While trials have been on hold since President Barack Obama announced the planned closure of Guanatanamo [JURIST report] in January, the government declared its intention in a filing with the US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit in the case of Ramzi bin al-Shibh [JURIST news archive], a Guantanamo detainee who has been held since 2002. The government filed a brief in response to a motion to stay proceedings and a petition [texts, PDF] to rule the Military Commissions Act of 2006 [text, PDF] unconstitutional [JURIST report] filed by al-Shibh's lawyers. One of the options being considered by the administration to handle the cases of the more than 200 detainees still at Guantanamo is moving the trials to federal court [Washington Post report], an option that is also being considered for al-Shibh.
While the Obama administration decides what to do with Guantanamo detainees who are under investigation or who have been charged with crimes, a number of former detainees are being relocated around the globe. On Wednesday, Hungary said that it would select one Guantanamo detainee [JURIST report] to be relocated who is not under investigation by the US, and who cannot return to his home country. Earlier this month, three Chinese Uighur Muslims agreed [JURIST report] to be relocated to the Pacific island nation of Palau. In late August, Portugal accepted two Syrian nationals , and five other EU members agreed [JURIST reports] to give serious consideration to receiving former detainees.


Link |
|
subscribe |
|
latest newscast |
archive |
Facebook page

|

California courts implementing monthly closures to ease budget crisis
Brian Jackson on September 17, 2009 11:51 AM ET

[JURIST] California courts were closed Wednesday in the first of what will be a monthly shut down of the judiciary in an effort to reduce the state's budget gap. The closures were authorized as part of California Code 68070 [text], which allows for closure of the courts one day per month, "for the transaction of judicial business for one day per month and may adopt rules of court to implement this section." While the move may slow some court business, one provision of the code does mandate that a court officer:
be available for the signing of any necessary documents on an emergency basis during the time a court is closed under this section on the same basis as a judicial officer is available on Saturdays, Sundays, and judicial holidays, and any other time a court is closed.
California court employees held a rally [San Jose Mercury News report] Wednesday to protest the closures, arguing that court closures harm the public, an opinion echoed [SDNN report] by California Supreme Court Chief Justice Ronald George [official profile]. The once monthly court closures, which will take place the third Wednesday of each month until June 2010, are expected to save the state [AP report] approximately $84 million.
Court closures are the latest money-saving tactic employed by California in the wake of state-wide budget issues, including a $26.3 billion state budget deficit [TIME report]. The Regents of the University of California recently indicated they would agree to student fee increases [San Jose Mercury News report] of 32 percent, one day after students and faculty at the 10 state-wide campuses called for a walkout [San Francisco Chronicle report] on the first scheduled day of classes to protest how the UC system has handled the budget crisis. In Los Angeles, the city council on Wednesday approved a plan for layoffs and furloughs [Los Angeles Times report] for city employees to counter the city's $400 million budget shortfall.


Link |
|
subscribe |
|
latest newscast |
archive |
Facebook page

|

FBI director reports on terrorism interrogations at Senate Judiciary hearing
Jaclyn Belczyk on September 17, 2009 10:47 AM ET

[JURIST] FBI Director Robert Mueller [official profile] addressed the FBI's role in leading the new specialized interrogation group to question top terrorist suspects as well as many other topics in a wide ranging oversight hearing [materials; recorded video] before the Senate Judiciary Committee [official website] Wednesday. Mueller said that the new interrogation panel [JURIST report] will be a "joint effort" between the FBI and the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) [official website]. In prepared remarks, Mueller said that while "safeguarding ... national security remains [the] primary concern," the FBI has also been making progress in other areas, such as combating white collar and violent crime. Mueller said that as of July 31, the FBI had more than 2,600 mortgage fraud cases pending, up from 1,600 cases in 2008, and that the agency has redirect resources into this area. Mueller also responded to a question about a recent Associated Press report [text] that the FBI and the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF) [official website] have been in conflict over each agency's responsibilities, saying that "as the inspector general points out, there are still issues." Mueller also denied that there is a proposal under consideration to strip protections from FBI whistleblowers.
Last month, the New York Times reported [text; JURIST report] that eight years after 9/11 [JURIST news archive], counterterrorism efforts continue to dominate the operations and budget of the FBI. Since the attacks, the bureau has doubled the number of agents it assigns to counterterrorism efforts and has created specialized "threat squads" to investigate possible threats. In March, Mueller told the Judiciary Committee that the rise in financial fraud investigations is limiting the ability [JURIST report] of the FBI to fight other crimes. In February, the FBI announced [JURIST report] that it was looking at shifting a number of agents from national security and counter terrorism activities to investigations involving financial fraud.


Link |
|
subscribe |
|
latest newscast |
archive |
Facebook page

|

EPA to review national smog standards regulations
Christian Ehret on September 17, 2009 9:37 AM ET

[JURIST] The US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) [official website] on Wednesday announced [press release] that they would reconsider 2008 national smog standards regulations [text] to ensure accuracy and public health. After a thorough review of the scientific methods behind the existing standards, the EPA will propose revisions by December and will issue a final decision by August 2010. Ground-level ozone, referred to as smog, has been linked to respiratory health issues and adverse effects on the environment. EPA Administrator Lisa Jackson addressed the decision to reconsider, saying:
This is one of the most important protection measures we can take to safeguard our health and our environment. Smog in the air we breathe can cause difficulty breathing and aggravate asthma, especially in children. Reconsidering these standards and ensuring acceptable levels of ground-level ozone could cut health care costs and make our cities healthier, safer places to live, work and play.
In addition to reviewing the current standards, the agency will also study the findings of the Clean Air Scientific Advisory Committee [official website], which originally recommended stricter requirements.
The decision to review the smog standards came in response to a legal challenge [JURIST report] filed by Earthjustice [advocacy website] on behalf of several environmental organizations. The suit alleged that the EPA ignored the input of top scientists before issuing its smog regulations [JURIST report] in March 2008. The EPA has the power to monitor ozone levels under the Clean Air Act [text, PDF].


Link |
|
subscribe |
|
latest newscast |
archive |
Facebook page

|

US closes controversial Camp Bucca prison in Iraq
Christian Ehret on September 17, 2009 7:37 AM ET

[JURIST] The US closed [press release] the Camp Bucca [backgrounder] prison facility in Southern Iraq Wednesday, pursuant to the Status of Forces Agreement (SOFA) [text, PDF]. The remaining detainees were transferred from Camp Bucca, once the largest US detention facility in Iraq, to the two remaining US prison facilities, Camp Cropper and Camp Taji. Since the SOFA took effect on January 1, 5,703 prisoners have been released [JURIST report], while 8,305 remain in US custody. According to the agreement, the Iraqi government must have arrest warrants or detention orders to accept transferred prisoners into Iraqi facilities, otherwise risking release. Under the SOFA, the US must release all prisoners or transfer them to the control of the Iraqi government by 2011.
In anticipation of prisoner releases and transfers, the US began building a facility [JURIST report] in July to train Iraqi corrections officers. In November, Iraqi human rights activists expressed concern about the treatment of detainees [JURIST report] due to be transferred from US military custody to Iraqi authorities under the then-proposed security agreement. In August 2008, the US military said that it had released more than 10,000 Iraqi detainees [JURIST report] over the past year. Also that month, six US sailors were charged [JURIST report] for allegedly abusing detainees at Camp Bucca. Camp Bucca was at the center of controversy in 2003 when the so-called Taguba report [text, PDF] detailed instances of detainee abuse and found that the detention camp was well over its carrying capacity.


Link |
|
subscribe |
|
latest newscast |
archive |
Facebook page

|

Myanmar authorities bar Suu Kyi from attending appeal hearing
Ximena Marinero on September 17, 2009 7:05 AM ET

[JURIST] Myanmar authorities have denied [AFP report] a request from opposition pro-democracy advocate Aung San Suu Kyi [BBC profile; JURIST news archive] to attend arguments on her appeal, her National League for Democracy (NLD) [party website] party told the Agence France-Presse Wednesday. NLD spokesperson and lawyer for Suu Kyi, Nyan Win, said an application to the police special information branch to be present for Friday's arguments was rejected. Government officials defended [AP report] that decision Thursday in commentary published in state newspaper Myanma Ahlin [text, PDF, in Burmese/Myanmar], saying that unless the court specifically required the presence of a defendant, the appeals process, including judgment, could be completed without her presence.
Earlier this month, the Divisional Court in Rangoon agreed to hear the appeal of Suu Kyi's recent conviction [JURIST reports] for violating state security laws. Suu Kyi was sentenced to an additional 18 months of house arrest for allowing American John Yettaw to stay in her home after he swam across a lake to get there. Yettaw, who was sentenced to seven years in prison with four years of hard labor, was released [JURIST report] last month after negotiations with US Senator Jim Webb (D-VA). Suu Kyi has spent 14 of the last 20 years in detention, and her latest conviction has been condemned [BBC report] by many world leaders and has given rise to international sanctions [JURIST report] against Myanmar's junta and members of the judiciary.


Link |
|
subscribe |
|
latest newscast |
archive |
Facebook page

|
| For more legal news check the Paper Chase Archive...
|
|
|