JURIST Supported by the University of Pittsburgh

 Same-Sex Marriage

The heated debate over same-sex marriage is one of the most polarizing issues currently facing the American legal community. It is a controversy being played out in every branch of the federal government, from the floor of the US Senate to the Oval Office. It has raised concerns over the nature of federalism, the constitutional protections afforded on the basis of sexual identity, and the role which societal values ultimately play in the formation of public policy. The American Bar Association's (ABA) endorsement of same-sex marriage in August 2010, and the official repeal of Don't Ask, Don't Tell in September 2011 seem to indicate a trend toward the legal recognition of same-sex marriage. However, while President Barack Obama has affirmed his support for the repeal of the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA), enforcement of the law continues and heavy legislative opposition to same-sex marriage has prevented its repeal. The stage has been set in the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit for what could eventually be a definitive ruling on same-sex marriage. The Ninth Circuit heard oral arguments in December 2011 on the state of California's same-sex marriage ban, Proposition 8. The case is widely expected to eventually end up in the US Supreme Court.... [more]

  TIMELINE

4/10/12: Nevada same-sex marriage ban challenged

4/3/12: Judge ruled denying benefits to federal employee's same-sex spouses is discriminatory

4/2/12: Bi-national same-sex couples filed suit challenging DOMA

3/1/12: Maryland became the eighth state to allow same-sex marriage
 
2/24/12: US lawmakers decided to appeal Defense of Marriage Act ruling

2/23/12: Maryland Senate sent same-sex marriage bill to governor

2/22/12: Federal judge found Defense of Marriage Act unconstitutional

2/21/12: Maryland Senate committee approved same-sex marriage bill

...[more]
  ACADEMIC COMMENTARY
Forum: Attempting to Preserve Equal Protection for Gays and Lesbians
Forum: Proposition 8 and the Metaphysics of Marriage
Forum: Revisiting Standing: Proposition 8 in the Ninth Circuit
  LEGAL PROFESSIONAL COMMENTARY
Hotline: Military Benefits for Same-Sex Spouses Advances Equality
Hotline: Perry Poses Problems for Same-Sex Marriage Advocates
Hotline: Petitioner Privacy Rights Lost Amid Marriage Equality Fight
  STUDENT COMMENTARY
Dateline: Judicial Activism and the Recognition of Same-Sex Marriage
Dateline: Same-Sex Marriage and International Law in the Ninth Circuit
Dateline: Obama and Congress Should Work Together to Repeal DOMA